top of page

What Should You Ask Before Hiring a Digital Marketing Agency?

Oct 26
5 min read

Updated: 3 days ago


Hiring a marketing agency is easy enough. Figuring out what you’re actually hiring it to accomplish takes a better conversation.


You might hear about rankings, advertising campaigns, website improvements, and content calendars. Those can all have a place. But a list of services doesn’t tell you whether the work fits your business.


Before hiring a digital marketing agency, ask how it will identify your priorities, what it will deliver, how results will be measured, what you’ll pay, and what you’ll control if the relationship ends.


I’d also pay attention to the questions the agency asks you. A useful recommendation needs more context than your website address and your available budget.


Here’s what I’d bring to the conversation.



1. What Do You Need To Understand Before Recommending Anything?

An agency should want to understand your services, customers, capacity, and current marketing.


For a home-service contractor, I’d expect questions like:


  • Which projects do you want more of?

  • Where can you realistically serve customers?

  • What usually makes someone choose your company?

  • How do inquiries arrive, and who responds?

  • What have you already tried?

  • Can you handle additional work right now?


A painting company looking for larger residential projects needs a different approach from one trying to fill short gaps with smaller jobs.


If both receive the same recommendation before anyone asks about those differences, I’d ask how the plan was developed.


You don’t need a complete strategy during an introductory call. You should hear enough thoughtful questions to believe the eventual strategy will fit.


2. What Would You Prioritize First, and Why?

Ask the agency to explain its proposed starting point in plain language.

Maybe your website attracts visitors but doesn’t clearly explain your services. Maybe your business has strong referrals but limited search visibility.


Maybe inquiries arrive regularly and sit unanswered.


Those situations call for different priorities.


I’d ask:


“Based on what you know so far, what would you investigate first, and what evidence would change your recommendation?”


That leaves room for an honest preliminary assessment without pretending an introductory conversation is a completed audit.


An agency should be able to connect its recommendations to a business need.


“You need more content” deserves a follow-up: content about what, for whom, and to help accomplish what?


3. What Exactly Will You Deliver?

“Monthly marketing” is a billing description. It needs a scope behind it.


Ask what the agreement includes, such as:

  • Which website pages will be created or improved.

  • Which advertising campaigns will be managed.

  • Whether writing, photography, or design is included.

  • What ongoing SEO work involves.

  • How often you’ll meet and receive updates.

  • How revisions and additional requests are handled.


Also ask who implements recommendations. An audit that identifies problems and a service that fixes them are different purchases.


You don’t need every future task predicted. You do need clear responsibilities, deliverables, and a process for approving changes.


Otherwise, “I thought that was included” becomes an expensive recurring meeting.



4. How Will We Decide Whether the Work Is Helping?


Agree on meaningful outcomes before the first report arrives.


For a contractor, I’d want to understand the path from inquiry to suitable project, estimate, and booked work.


Traffic, rankings, and advertising clicks can help explain performance. They don’t tell the entire business story.


Ask how the agency will distinguish legitimate inquiries from spam, requests outside your service area, and work you don’t provide. Then ask what information it needs from your team.


For example, an agency may identify a form submission, while your office knows whether that person requested a suitable project and accepted an estimate.


My recommendation is to combine those perspectives. A report becomes more useful when someone can explain what happened after the click.


5. What Can You Reasonably Promise?

An agency can commit to defined work, communication, and agreed processes. Be cautious when commitments turn into certainty about outcomes outside its control.


For SEO specifically, Google’s guidance on hiring an SEO recommends asking about expected results, measurement, experience, and communication. It also warns against providers guaranteeing first place in search results.


Ask for the assumptions behind an estimate:


“What needs to be true for this plan to work, and what could limit the results?”


You’re looking for a credible explanation of opportunity and uncertainty.


For timing, Google’s SEO Starter Guide explains that changes can take hours to several months to affect search results, and some won’t produce a noticeable impact. That isn’t a deadline for booked jobs.


6. What Will the Total Investment Include?

Ask for the complete cost of operating the proposed plan.


Depending on the scope, that could involve setup, ongoing management, advertising spend, website subscriptions, paid tools, content production, or additional development.


Clarify which expenses are included, which are separate, and which require your approval.


If paid ads are involved, ask how much goes toward media and how much pays for management. If a website is involved, ask about ongoing hosting, maintenance, and app subscriptions.


Also understand the agreement length, renewal process, cancellation notice, and treatment of unfinished work.


I’d rather resolve those details while everyone is excited about the project than during a disagreement six months later.


7. What Will My Business Own and Control?

Have the agency explain account access and ownership before work begins.


I’d ask about your domain, website, advertising accounts, analytics, business profiles, and creative files.


Find out what belongs to your business, what is licensed, and what can be transferred.


Then ask a simple question:


“If we stop working together, what will I keep, and what will the handoff involve?”


The answer may vary by platform and agreement. Get it in writing.


You should understand who pays subscriptions, who has administrative access, and whether moving elsewhere would require rebuilding anything.


8. Who Will Do the Work, and What Will You Need From Me?

Ask who your main contact will be, who performs the work, and whether outside specialists are involved.


There’s nothing inherently wrong with a team using contractors. You should understand who is responsible for quality and communication.


Your responsibilities matter, too. The agency may need approved photos, accurate service details, timely feedback, or updates on inquiry outcomes.


Finally, ask to see relevant work and have the agency explain its contribution. A polished website is useful evidence of design ability; it doesn’t establish who generated the leads or closed the sales.


Choose a Partner Whose Reasoning You Understand

At Matt Davis Marketing, I approach the work through Diagnose, Build, Refine: understand the problem, build what addresses it, then improve the work using evidence.


That’s the kind of reasoning I’d encourage you to look for in any agency conversation.


You should leave knowing what happens next, why it matters, what it costs, and how you’ll evaluate progress.


Need help with your website, local SEO strategy, or paid ads? Let’s talk about your marketing at Matt Davis Marketing. We can discuss your priorities and identify a sensible starting point for your business. Thanks for reading!


-Matt Davis
-Matt Davis


bottom of page